There is a new coupon available for Peanut Butter & Co peanut butter. You can buy one get one free up to $5.99.
This is a limited print so it is not something you want to wait to grab.
These are more expensive peanut butters- probably about $5 per jar at stores like Target and Whole Foods. If you like to get the natural varieties of PB without high fructose corn syrup this is a great option.
I usually buy Maranatha Peanut Butter but I am going to give this a whirl. They also make chocolatey varieties and a cinnamon raisin that would be great with celery for the kiddos.
I will warn you this is one of those Java coupons that can be annoying. If you have any issues try changing browsers or you might need to upgrade your Java or just turn off your pop up blocker. I usually click Run this Time and it seems to work for me.